Featured Reviews
Rev. Larry Jones Senior Pastor New Hope Pentecostal Holiness Church Newport News, VA

"The service was prompt and they were willing to listen to whatever our situation was. That is why we have been with them [Church Mutual] for forty years."

Share your experience with us

Your loyalty as a Church Mutual customer is greatly appreciated. Please share your unique experience with us.


Lilydale First Baptist Church, Chicago, IL
Ebenezer Baptist Church, Atlanta, GA
The Center, Palos Park, IL
Faith Community Church, Wichita, KS

Zuiko Redding, Cedar Rapids, IA Sep, 2020

Twenty years ago when we first founded Cedar Rapids Zen Center (we're a Buddhist Temple), Church Mutual was about the only company who would insure an organization so small and new as we were.  Since then, we've always had fine service from them. Our roof was damaged by the derecho that blew through Iowa in early August, and when I called I reached an agent almost immediately.  The adjustor was out a few days later and I received the damage report and the check about two weeks after that.  We're now calling roofers. I've also had other interactions with Church Mutual folks and they've always been professional and helpful.  We have to do an audit for our workers' compensation each November and my questions and worries have always been addressed with clarity and good cheer. I'd recommend Church Mutual to any religious organization needing insurance of any kind.

John Cardillo, Conference Treasurer & Director of Admin Svcs United Methodist Church of Greater New Jersey Neptune, NJ Feb, 2018

Our partnership with Church Mutual has been excellent. Our relationship began with them writing our Workers Compensation insurance and grew to insuring all of our churches. Their cost, coverage and care for our churches has proven to be very reliable. This is a relationship we truly appreciate.

Diane Yerks, Assistant Business Manager Promiseland Church Austin, TX Dec, 2017

They are prompt and responsive and they are everything I would expect from an insurance company. No hassles, and easy to get a hold of people. For an insurance company, it was a great experience.

William Ruffle, Assistant Saint Matthews Lutheran Church Willmington, NC Nov, 2017

It [claim] was handled I believe very efficiently with a lot of consideration and care for me. It was not just about numbers, I got what I should have in return for the service.

Katie Donegan, Book Keeper Garner Creek Retreat Center Dickson, TN Nov, 2017

The customer service is great, everyone is easy to talk to on the phone, timing was very prompt. We do like that there isn't a lot of paperwork, Church Mutual handles all of that.

Vernice Schultz, St. John's Lutheran Church Loganville, WI Oct, 2017

They do what they say they are going to do and are one of the cheapest.

Brittany Buchannan, Business Office Manager Meridian Senior Living Santa Monica, CA Oct, 2017

Just easy. It was an easy process and they made sure they get back to us as fast as possible.

Reverened Donald Pryor, Pastor Foothills Christian Center Palo Cedro, CA Oct, 2017

They are very smooth, very professional. The claim in general was very well handled. I would highly recommended to any church.

Tyrone Miller, Deacon Fairview Baptist Church Gretna, VA Jun, 2017

They are a great insurance company and have been great to the church... they answer questions and do whatever is needed.

Adell Quinn, Treasurer and Trustee Christ Temple Church Of Personal Experience Boston, MA Jun, 2017

They are trustworthy and conducted business thoroughly, and quickly. They explained everything. We had very big insurance companies, and Church Mutual was superior.

Join the Conversation! Facebook LinkedIn Youtube Instagram

Church Mutual Insurance Company, S.I. (a stock insurer)
P.O. Box 357 | 3000 Schuster Lane | Merrill, WI 54452-0357
Telephone (800) 554-2642 or (715) 536-5577

© 2021 Church Mutual Insurance Company, S.I. All rights reserved. Protecting the Greater Good is a registered trademark of Church Mutual Insurance Company, S.I.

Church Mutual is a stock insurer whose policyholders are members of the parent mutual holding company formed on 1/1/20. S.I. = a stock insurer.